lindaikeji35

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Step-Throughs: an Advantage in Traffic?

Posted on 2:02 AM by dvdsvdsdv
There was an interesting post on ecovelo yesterday, where the author compared how he uses his three transportation bikes: a Rivendell Sam Hillborne, a Surly Long Haul Trucker, and a Civia Loring. All three bicycles are set up with upright handlebars and decent load carrying capacity, but the Civia differs from the other two in that it has a fairly low stepover. And according to the author, the combination of its "upright riding position, step-through frame, and internal gear hub make[s] the Loring exceptionally confidence inspiring for riding slowly when in close proximity to pedestrians and automobile traffic." Initially, I read past that sentence with the kind of matter-of-fact acceptance that goes with processing what you already consider to be a given. But then later I mentally "rewound" and thought "Wait a minute, he is saying that he finds it more comfortable to ride a step-through in traffic than a diamond frame - Is this a generally accepted notion?" 

I used to think the reason I prefer step-throughs for transportation, is that I often wear skirts. But having read the ecovelo post, I realise that even when wearing trousers I feel better on a step-through in traffic. And, assuming that Alan of ecovelo mostly wears trousers, for him there must be other factors involved as well. Maybe for me it's the promise of the easy "hop off sideways" dismount should I need to bail, that makes me feel more secure. But to tell the truth, I am not sure what it is, and whether my preference is entirely logical.

All factors remaining equal (upright handlebars, ride quality, load capacity), what, if anything, would make a step-through bike an advantage in traffic?
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in loop frame, urban cycling | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Cream Tires Directory
    It is no secret that I like cream bicycle tires. If you are a fan as well, you will find this recent thread on bikeforums a real treat - lo...
  • Rediscovering Familiar Places... and the Hills You Never Knew Were There
    Yesterday was a special occasion for us, and we wanted to do something special to celebrate. We decided to visit an area of Seacoast New Ham...
  • 'Off Label' Use
    In pharmacological jargon, there is a term, "off label use," that refers to a treatment being used successfully for something othe...
  • Tall Boots, Zippers, and Mixte Stays
    If you ride a mixte with twin lateral stays and wear tall boots with zippers along the inseams, you may notice that the zippers can rub agai...
  • Handlebar Hoopla, What Now?
    My  Royal H Mixte  is almost built up, save for the fenders, racks and lights. I don't want to post glamour shots before the bike is com...
  • The Allure of the Handlebar Bag
    [from the May 1973 issue of National Geographic; image via gustav531 ] Maybe it was seeing too many images like this one. [image via Harriet...
  • Adjustable Stem!
    When I wrote about wanting a longer stem on one of my bikes , several people suggested I get ahold of a vintage adjustable stem. I did not k...
  • What Does 'Commuting' Mean to You?
    Some of us have conventionally structured jobs, where we ride our bikes to the office, stay there for a given period of time, then ride home...
  • 5-Speed Conversion!
    My conversion of the Mercier mixte to a 5-speed is pretty much complete, and it worked out nicely. I've received some questions about t...
  • Threadless Stems: the Good, the Bad and the Ugly
    With the Urbana bike temporarily in my possession and the Surly bikes we rode last week-end, I have suddenly undergone a crash course in...

Categories

  • ANT
  • art
  • bags
  • basket
  • beginners
  • Bella Ciao
  • bicycle events
  • bicycle industry
  • bicycle reviews
  • bike friends
  • bike shopping
  • blog development
  • blogiversary
  • books
  • Boston
  • Brompton
  • Brooks
  • Cape Cod
  • cargo bikes
  • cars
  • cats
  • children
  • clipless
  • clothing
  • Co-Habitant
  • coaster brake
  • comfort
  • Constance
  • countryside
  • diamond frame
  • DIY
  • DL-1
  • dress guards
  • drop bars
  • Eustacia Vye
  • fashion industry
  • fenders
  • films
  • fixed gear
  • flowers
  • food
  • framebuilding
  • Gazelle
  • Geekhouse
  • gender
  • give-away
  • grips
  • handlebars
  • handmade
  • holidays
  • Interbike
  • Italian bicycles
  • Jacqueline
  • knitting
  • lights
  • local bike shops
  • locking up
  • loop frame
  • lugs
  • Maine
  • Marianne
  • mercian
  • Mercier
  • mixte
  • Moser
  • Motobecane
  • Myles
  • night time cycling
  • North Shore
  • paceline
  • Pashley
  • pilen
  • poll
  • product reviews
  • racks
  • rain
  • Raleigh
  • Randonneur
  • randonneuring
  • restoration
  • Rivendell
  • roadcycling
  • rod brakes
  • Rodney
  • Romania
  • Royal H
  • Royal H. Mixte
  • saddles
  • safety
  • Seven
  • shop visits
  • silliness
  • skirt
  • social commentary
  • Soma
  • somervillain
  • stories
  • summer cycling
  • sun and heat
  • Surly
  • tandem
  • technique
  • test rides
  • tires
  • tools
  • traffic
  • trails
  • transportation options
  • travel
  • unpaved
  • urban cycling
  • Urbana
  • Velo Orange
  • Velouria
  • Vienna
  • vintage
  • winter cycling

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2011 (236)
    • ►  September (17)
    • ►  August (22)
    • ►  July (26)
    • ►  June (27)
    • ►  May (27)
    • ►  April (26)
    • ►  March (30)
    • ▼  February (30)
      • Bicycle Shopping: What Do We Expect?
      • Moultons, Modern and Vintage
      • No Car, Must Travel
      • On Handmade Bicycle Shows
      • Hand Brazing a Bicycle Frame
      • First vs Second Winter of Cycling
      • Budget Roadbike for a Novice? Help a Sister Out!
      • Lug Samesies! Vintage Bianchi vs Trek
      • Right Up Front
      • Choosing Your Gospel: Rivendell vs Bicycle Quarterly
      • Tricks of the Camera
      • The Pashley Princess: a Retrospective from a Forme...
      • Manufacturers with 'History': Does Continuity Matter?
      • Is the Wheel Lock a Useful Feature?
      • Misadventures in the Thaw
      • Valentine and Anti-Valentine Give-Aways
      • A Question of Favourites
      • Hats Off!
      • Should I Care About Cadence?
      • Getting to Know You
      • When Does a Customer Turn Designer?
      • Step-Throughs: an Advantage in Traffic?
      • Remembering a Man I Never Knew
      • Turn Signals and Brake Lights: Can It Be Done, Ele...
      • A Monday Cocktail and a Cat in a Hat
      • Skinny, Wide, or Stay the Heck Inside?
      • When a Bike Is Not for You, What to Do?
      • Cycling Indoors: the Kurt Kinetic Trainer
      • Cycling and Statistics
      • The 'Lady's Bicycle': Descriptive, Offensive, or M...
    • ►  January (31)
  • ►  2010 (262)
    • ►  December (28)
    • ►  November (29)
    • ►  October (24)
    • ►  September (23)
    • ►  August (25)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (20)
    • ►  May (19)
    • ►  April (20)
    • ►  March (17)
    • ►  February (18)
    • ►  January (14)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

dvdsvdsdv
View my complete profile